Good intentioned. A good education is and will always be one of the best thing you can give children.
No genocides. Even the upper claimed amount of deaths ~6000 out of 150k. At the start of the program in 1831, the life expectancy in the US was like 35ish, and slowly rose. (no data for Canada)
Poor results. IMO a lot of natives don't agree with my first statement regarding education... so... ?
Lefties insist that RS arose through nothing but evil intentions. That the millions we spent on RS, even in depth of the great recession, was only out of maliciousness. That the priest and educators who devoted their lives to educating these children, did so only because they were sadists.
Educating aboriginals was an impossible and unrewarding task. They spoke 150+ languages, none of which had any form of writing. They were itinerant and isolated so reaching them was expensive. Their cultures were millennia behind the west. Broken homes, alcoholism, and violence were common place. Kids had no role models and no interest in leaning.
Yet, as you say, education was the only solution. What chance would they have if without it, not even speaking English or French? We ought to praise both the educators and the students who learned.
So were residential school good or bad boys?
Good intentioned. A good education is and will always be one of the best thing you can give children.
No genocides. Even the upper claimed amount of deaths ~6000 out of 150k. At the start of the program in 1831, the life expectancy in the US was like 35ish, and slowly rose. (no data for Canada)
Poor results. IMO a lot of natives don't agree with my first statement regarding education... so... ?
Lefties insist that RS arose through nothing but evil intentions. That the millions we spent on RS, even in depth of the great recession, was only out of maliciousness. That the priest and educators who devoted their lives to educating these children, did so only because they were sadists.
Educating aboriginals was an impossible and unrewarding task. They spoke 150+ languages, none of which had any form of writing. They were itinerant and isolated so reaching them was expensive. Their cultures were millennia behind the west. Broken homes, alcoholism, and violence were common place. Kids had no role models and no interest in leaning.
Yet, as you say, education was the only solution. What chance would they have if without it, not even speaking English or French? We ought to praise both the educators and the students who learned.