Please, since we're not in the States try to use normal political terminology. Your are describing the difference between a constitutional representative democracy and anarchy. The U.S. Canada, Australia, the U.K., etc are constitutional representative democracies, so say so. A republic is simply a form of government that doesn't have a monarch, it has nothing to do with democracy, tyranny or anything else. My advice is expand your political science education beyond sovereign citizen web forums.
Could you please let Ben Franklin rest in peace? By your definition every western nation is a "republic".
Please, since we're not in the States try to use normal political terminology. Your are describing the difference between a constitutional representative democracy and anarchy. The U.S. Canada, Australia, the U.K., etc are constitutional representative democracies, so say so. A republic is simply a form of government that doesn't have a monarch, it has nothing to do with democracy, tyranny or anything else. My advice is expand your political science education beyond sovereign citizen web forums.