Remains of 215 children found at former residential school in British Columbia
(toronto.citynews.ca)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (50)
sorted by:
There is and was a church on site and it didn't burn down.
It's not, because the mortality rate of school aged children to the Spanish flu was the lowest of all age groups. The mortality rate of children aged 5 to 19 was about 20 to 30 per 100,000. It was the deadliest for adults (20 to 50) with a death rate of over 1,000 per 100,000 (more than 20 times than the mortality rate for kids) and really old people 65+.
Next you're going to say Covid is really deadly for children.
IF IF IF ... Look. 200 deaths during the Spanish Flu would mean that almost all kids in the school died within a 3 day period. Do you really think that no one would know about this? That no one would ask about the 200 dead kids within 3 days? That no one would write about? Not a priest, not a nun, not a reporter, not a city employee, not a staff member? You might be delusional if you believe that. Especially if you combine it with low mortality rate for children regarding the Spanish Flu.
And I guarantee you that these 200 kids didn't die within 3 days. You pull out these almost impossible theories out of your ass and speculate about them. Maybe there was an asteroid which hit the school and killed everyone? Who knows? Am I right?
Somehow you think that 200 kids died in a short time span 5 minutes away from the city center of Kamloops and yet nobody knows something about it.
Show me one document that shows that schools slaughtered live stock on school premises? Just one and I will believe you.
Another point where this argument falls flat is that radar they used to locate the mass grave, was used to locate coffins and not bones. Do you think that after slaughtering the livestock the remnants of these animals were buried in coffins? Are you retarded?
It was hidden. The school was run by the Catholic Church. An institution which has no issues documenting every body which is buried on their cemeteries, but as soon as they are at fault for something (be it pedophile priests or deaths at residential schools) they lack any documentation. And yet somehow you give this institution the benefit of doubt. It wouldn't be the first time or even a surprise if the Catholic Church hid these dead children, like with any other of their failures.
It wasn't. There was no hospital prior to the school.
Funny how the Spanish Flu killed almost all children of a school though the mortality rate for school aged children was the lowest of all groups.
Here is the most likely scenario and not these made-up stories of yours:
Over several decades over 200 kids died at this residential school in Kamloops. Due to abuse, lack of care, starvation and sicknesses. The staff of the school and the Catholic Church didn't care about these death. They buried these kids in the backyard of the school like garbage, without any documentation. And now we have an undocumented mass grave behind the school.
You can even see how much the Catholic Church cared about the children if you look up the official documentation of deaths at residential schools. Most of the time they didn't even name the kids. All they wrote down how many kids died within a year., but no names and no ages. The Catholic Church and the Canadian government just didn't care about these "savages".
You're making excuses up for a time were even the Prime Minister of Canada wrote letters to his peers that keeping the First Nations on the brink of starvation and moving them to far away communities without arable land is the best way to keep them down. Yet somehow it's not the most likely scenario for you that the Canadian government and the Catholic Church just didn't care about the kids in residential school and that this is the reason why we now have mass graves behind residential schools.
I bet this will be only the beginning. Now the feds will search for these graves on the premises of other residential schools. And they will find them.
While it's true that the Spanish Flu had a bigger impact on the First Nations, I want to see prove that it wiped out "entie Haida settlements". According to the provincial government of BC around 800 to 1,200 First Nation members died during the Spanish Flu.
And after the quarantine? Why didn't the agent for the reserve write the provincial or federal government about it?
????? What?
The school is a kilometer away from the city. A KILOMETER. That is not a big distance. Someone can walk backwards a kilometer within 15 minutes.
I already "proposed" causes and timelines of death. While you are arguing that these kids died all at once, I already stated that these kids were buried over decades.
Scenario A is more likely. And here is the proof. When I looked up the Spanish Flu deaths on First Nation reserves in BC you can find numbers between 800 and 1,200. I asked myself, surely 200 dead First Nation kids would have been quite the story. The indian agent would have written the provincial government about it. There should be letters. If not in the archives of the school, they should in the archives of the provincial government. And there are letters from the residential school in Kamloops to the provincial and federal government.
From May 1921:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00573.jpg
A request for money for the 5 extra students which were admitted to the school, because their parents died to the Flu. They also state how many children are currently at the school. 60 children are currently at the school.
Next letter is from October 1921:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00593.jpg
Students at the school: 68
Letter from the principal of the school, October 1922:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00653.jpg
The principal writes the Super Intendant about plans to expand the school. And that a school with enough place for less than 250 would be a mistake.
Letter from November 3rd 1922:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00652.jpg
The Deputy Super Intendant of BC thanks the principal for the numbers.
Letter from December 1925:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00613.jpg
The school now houses over 135 students. The government gives the OK to expand it to 150.
Letter from May 1926:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00661.jpg
A third wing is being built to accomodate even more students.
Letter from March 1930:
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00706.jpg
The school is now home to 275 students.
As you can see, the school wasn't home to 200 students during the Spanish Flu epidemic. It house 60 to 80 students at that time. Only after the pandemic the school was expanded to about 150 students by 1925, 275 students by 1930. It peaked at over 500 students in the 1950.
200 kids couldn't have died during the Spanish Flu at the school, because the school didn't even have that many students. There is even a letter from a nun to the federal government where she "thanks the lord for the remedies which helped the kids during the epidemic". Speak, these kids at the school didn't die from the Spanish Flu.
https://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/microform/data2/dm09/d09/006003/c-8770/jpg/c-8770-00570.jpg
There was no former hospital. The school had only 60 students during the Spanish Flu pandemic. You two scenarios don't have any merit.
Kids got new names in residential schools as a way to integrate them in European society. Look up the official records of deaths at residential schools. They all have European sounding names.
They weren't paid. They were forced to live on these reserves.
You are speculating. From "former hospitals" to "200 kids dead in 3 days because of the Spanish Flu". Not a single theory of yours holds ground. All you have is hot air. You provided absolutely no proof for any of your claims.
The RCMP is already investigating the site. Just be aware, the average time till a human bones decompose to dust is about 80 years.
Also, you don't want the truth. If you wanted the truth you wouldn't make up impossible stories.
It's not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeletonization
"After skeletonization, if scavenging animals do not destroy or remove the bones, acids in many fertile soils take about 20 years to completely dissolve the skeleton of mid- to large-size mammals, such as humans, leaving no trace of the organism."
With a modern coffin which protects the dead body the time can be prolonged to about 80 years. But since these kids at the residential school were only buried in cheap wooden boxes ...
If they died more than 50 or 60 years ago, there will be nothing left of them anymore.
Because Naia died in a cave. In dry conditions skeletons can fossilize.
"Alternately, especially in very fine, dry, salty, anoxic, or mildly alkaline soils, bones may undergo fossilization, converting into minerals that may persist indefinitely."
Your theory is already impossible by the simple fact that there weren't even 200 kids at the school at the time. Only 60 to 70.
I stated multiple causes and they are all verifiable by people who went to such schools.
The chance there are still remains of these kids is pretty much zero.