I just want the government to keep mandating it.
The Nazis were great about mandating medical experiments that have no safety data too.
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (40)
sorted by:
No there is a basis in truth to all literary allegorical elements. You chose to say there's no basis and they chose to try to discredit the literary tool as not based in some fact. How would you determine if someone had left a ghetto and then get shot? Were their papers out of date? How would they get legal authority to commit the act by the regime without some predicate.
You are saying that the guards could just "tell" and the story of the papers in Casablanca was completely fabricated.
The kernel of truth in the story was the practice was from stories heard in the thirties and the harsh outcomes as noted.
So you choosing to ignore the Holocaust and what we should learn from it is very telling. Almost as if you wish it to never have happened because you wish to justify the use of their techniques.
Spare me the bullshit.
You made that statement in a conversation comparing proof of vaccination to Nazi medical experiments.
Nothing you have supplied supports that statement.
You see Anither,
I’m here defending the Nazi’s because unlike the Trudeau Government, I claim the Nazis didn’t implement a hygiene pass or a health pass. Only Trudeau did.
However, like the Socialist Nazis, Trudeau DID implement check points to check hygiene status and he DID jail the healthy citizens and put them in camps when they did not show ze papays!!
What else you got?
https://www.iwm.org.uk/history/daily-life-in-the-warsaw-ghetto
Permission was required to leave because typhus.
You are the one whose full of it. You want it to happen again I can only assume because you must have some affinity to medicalization of tyranny.
From your own link: "On 2 October 1940, Ludwig Fischer, Governor of the Warsaw District in the occupied General Government of Poland, signed the order to officially create a Jewish district (ghetto) in Warsaw. It was to become the largest ghetto in Nazi-occupied Europe.
The German administration deliberately limited food supplies to the absolute minimum which caused near starvation amongst the population from the very beginning of the ghetto's existence. Smuggling food, mainly by children, from the 'Aryan side' was the only option of providing the ghetto with supplies. Malnutrition, overpopulation and lack of medical care brought another deadly factor to the daily life of the ghetto's residents – typhus."
Confinement in the ghetto came first, because the Nazis were vicious anti-semites. The "permission" that was required to leave was in place before the typhus appeared.
Any attempt by you to compare those conditions to public health measures during pandemics in Canada since 1900 is defensible only as ignorance.
You failed to read "in the name of public health - Nazi Racial Hygiene by Susan Bachrach, ph.d" in which she covers the history of the conflation on typhus with the Jewish population and that policy being imported in 1939 to Poland.
It's in one of my links. You there will learn that part of the way the Germans treated typhus was as a racial disease.
They blamed the Jews for spreading it which then lead to the ghettos.
But you don't like that story because you want to justify the behaviour obviously.