Brownstone Institute : The Triumph of Natural Immunity ————————————————————— Tuchodi, why aren’t negative covid tests or proof of natural immunity sufficient? Provide a link to evidence (www.google.com)
posted ago by CanadianRighty ago by CanadianRighty +8 / -0
You'll find the science in the link you supplied: "Seropositivity for anti-N antibodies should not be interpreted as protection from future infection. Vaccination remains the safest strategy for preventing complications from SARS-CoV-2 infection, including hospitalization among children and adults (4,5). COVID-19 vaccination following infection provides additional protection against severe disease and hospitalization (6). Staying up to date††† with vaccination is recommended for all eligible persons, including those with previous SARS-CoV-2 infection."
Why isn't natural immunity or negative tests good enough for travel here, unlike other countries?
Science? Where’s the proof? Oh wait you have none, just your baseless claims.
Your own link references a science study that says vaccination is recommended, because "Seropositivity for anti-N antibodies should not be interpreted as protection from future infection." - meaning just surviving covid is not enough - and goes on to recommend getting vaccinated.
Why is that not good enough for you? It's not the opinion of some individual article writer. It's the result of the analysis of 5 recent months of data from 50 US states plus some territories, involving many tens of thousands of individual cases, by a team of trained scientists.
Is that not science enough for you?
Not enough, I want the science that shows the real world effectiveness of the infringements of constitutional rights.
Or you could just admit there is no evidence.
Your own post links to a study that shows that vaccination is the best protection. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7117e3.htm
Hospital records show that unvaccinated people are a greater burden on the healthcare system. Today's numbers from Ontario hospitals show 21% of the covid patients come from the 10% of the population that is not vaccinated.
Unvaccinated people should not be packed tightly into enclosed spaces breathing recirculated air with people who could be carrying the virus.
It's pretty simple.
Tuchodi posts: ”vaccination is the best protection.” FALSE.
1. THE FULLY VACCINATED HAVE THE HIGHEST RATE OF COVID INFECTIONS
2. THE COVID VACCINE FAILED 85% OF HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS
3. Dr Zain Chagla, infectious diseases specialist confirms VACCINE STATUS IS IRRELEVANT IN THE ICU.
Nope. Overall the vaccines reduce the damage the virus does.
28 February 2022 "in the six-month period July to December 2021, the estimated relative risk of admission to Jersey General Hospital due to clinical COVID for those aged 40 and over was 3.5-14.4 times greater in those who had received less than two doses of COVID vaccine than in those who received two or more doses of the vaccine." https://www.gov.je/Health/Coronavirus/CoronavirusDocuments/R%20COVID%20Cases%20Vaccine%20Status%20Report.pdf
Nov. 25, 2021 "Unvaccinated people are about six times more likely to test positive than vaccinated people, nine times more likely to be hospitalized, and 14 times more likely to die from COVID-related complications" https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/covid-19-vaccine/news/20211124/unvaccinated-14-times-more-likely-to-die-from-covid
No one can tell if that's true by reading your post, can they?
POSTING INACCURATE REPORTING AGAIN TUCHODI? Not very scientific don’t you think? Why keep posting ONTARIO DASHBOARD when you know it has a disclaimer warning that their reporting is incomplete and inaccurate. Why are you knowingly posting inaccurate reporting Tuchodi?
Dr Zain Chagla, infectious diseases specialist confirms VACCINE STATUS IS IRRELEVANT IN THE ICU.
I don't suppose you could back that claim up with a link, eh? Nothing personal, but I think we shouldn't be expected to just take your word.
Or that one?
Why are you so angry Tuchodi when National Data proves that THE FULLY VACCINATED ARE AT HIGHER RISK OF COVID INFECTION?
You are a FRAUD